The Cathedral Contest
34 replies [Last post]
Kent0526
Contributor
Contributor
WoM Member: 73606
WoM Coins: 299

Starting at March 6, 2011, and ending at April 7, 2011, there will be a cathedral contest.

The criteria are as follows:
The church must be on your realm.
Build a church, any size, from any style/any time period.
The church can be a church of any religion
There might be a prize, I don't know. Depends on if someone will donate a prize for us.
If enough people sign up, I will divide the competition into tiers for each rank
Judges:
Sarari 
Kent0526
Ryanknack
Signing up:SIGN UPS ARE CLOSED
Current people in the contest:
Minecraft Username: Artful
WoM Rank: Artist
Minecraft Username: Dray2k
WoM Rank: Designer
Minecraft Username: Japetto9
WoM Rank: Designer
AlphaCheeseGuy16
WoM Rank: Designer
Minecraft Username: Swagalicos
WoM Rank: Artist
Minecraft Username: Danz360
WoM Rank: Designer

Minecraft Username: JansenProjects

WoM Rank: Designer
Minecraft Username: BizarreCake
WoM Rank: Surveyor
Minecraft Username: greenitthe123
WoM Rank: Worker
Minecraft Username: My_name_is_Tuna
WoM Rank: Builder
Minecraft Username: MineCraftt
WoM Rank: Designer
Minecraft Username: Eliethsor
WoM Rank: Surveyor
Minecraft Username: Comradeyeltsen

WoM Rank: Worker
Minecraft Username: Sinister_95
WoM Rank: Designer
Minecraft Username: Beardlessjoe
WoM Rank:  Builder
Minecraft Username: Gabriel365
WoM Rank: Surveyor
Minecraft Username: Dramaslims
WoM Rank: Designer
Minecraft Username: Relik420
WoM Rank: Artist
Minecraft Username: TehDarkKnight
WoM Rank: Worker
Minecraft Username: Joanan203
WoM Rank: Worker
Minecraft Username: Sillyvader
WoM Rank: Surveyor
Minecraft Username: Joe3355

WoM Rank: Designer

Minecraft Username: koffem

WoM Rank: Member
Helpful links:

nowusee
WoM Member
Members
WoM Member: 203489
WoM Coins: 21
I will judge.

I will judge.

Kent0526
Contributor
Contributor
WoM Member: 73606
WoM Coins: 299
Minecraft username, please?

Minecraft username, please?

nowusee
WoM Member
Members
WoM Member: 203489
WoM Coins: 21
Nowusee

Nowusee

greenitthe
WoM Member
Members
WoM Member: 130891
WoM Coins: 7
Reply

var fctb_tool=null;
function PA19U4_9IW86(t)
{
fctb_tool=t;
start(fctb_tool);
}

greenitthe123
Worker

I can help judge...
THat is if I am free, I shall check my schedule...

greenitthe
WoM Member
Members
WoM Member: 130891
WoM Coins: 7
Aw

var fctb_tool=null;
function WEkkc7bCDVL4(t)
{
fctb_tool=t;
start(fctb_tool);
}

Aw, just as I was starting my cathedral the server goes down D:

cheezychicken
WoM Member
Members
WoM Member: 1434
WoM Coins: 8
hi there.  I might join if i

hi there.  I might join if i can finish my racetrack soon enough :D

Evilking9090
WoM Member
Members
WoM Member: 188720
WoM Coins: 13
i would like to help

I have an occupied realm so i would like to judge, name is the same

Kent0526
Contributor
Contributor
WoM Member: 73606
WoM Coins: 299
Judges are picked

I will be accepting no more judges. The judges are Artful, Sarari, and GTRRetrospect

dahquan
WoM Member
Members
WoM Member: 127366
WoM Coins: 2
sign me up

Minecraft Username: MineCraftt
WoM Rank: Surveyor

sarari
WoM Member
Members
WoM Member: 25023
WoM Coins: 2
YEAH CONTEST YEAH, i'll judge

YEAH CONTEST YEAH, i'll judge :3

ComradeYeltsen
WoM Member
Members
WoM Member: 130182
WoM Coins: 0
OH YEAH

Comradeyeltsen

Worker

ryanknack
Member
Members
WoM Member: 173494
WoM Coins: 980
I would be more than happy to

I would be more than happy to judge if you would like :)

greenitthe
WoM Member
Members
WoM Member: 130891
WoM Coins: 7
Hmm

When it is time to judge, I apologize for having to sink in my cathedral, but I don't have enough voxels for the right height.

TehDarkKnight
WoM Member
Members
WoM Member: 117128
WoM Coins: 0
I would like to join.

I would like to join. Minecraft Name: TehDarkKnight World of Minecraft Rank: Worker

ComradeYeltsen
WoM Member
Members
WoM Member: 130182
WoM Coins: 0
Question

Are there any specific judging criteria for this? Or is it just kinda arbitrary?

Kent0526
Contributor
Contributor
WoM Member: 73606
WoM Coins: 299
Detail and structure will be

Detail and structure will be judged.

Also, size will not matter.

greenitthe
WoM Member
Members
WoM Member: 130891
WoM Coins: 7
>.<

OOOOh!
Terribly sorry, but I now am remebering that we got mid-terms this week and I don't have alot of time to play minecraft with studying, so I am gracefully withdrawing from the competion.

petergriffin123123
WoM Member
Members
WoM Member: 143384
WoM Coins: 2
Sounds interesting, I might

Sounds interesting, I might join, idk yet

celebrir
WoM Member
Members
WoM Member: 178923
WoM Coins: 54
Kent, you forgot me in the

Kent, you forgot me in the judge list! im Surveyor and if hollow buys me premium I'll be Designer

Joechicken
WoM Member
Members
WoM Member: 164914
WoM Coins: 0
Sign me up

In-game name: Joe3355

Rank: Designer

BizarreCake
WoM Member
Members
WoM Member: 173565
WoM Coins: 0
Minecraft Username:

Minecraft Username: BizarreCake
WoM Rank: Surveyor

JansenProjects
WoM Member
Members
WoM Member: 210501
WoM Coins: 0
I'll participate

Username: JansenProjects

Rank: Designer

koffem
WoM Member
Members
WoM Member: 201052
WoM Coins: 0
I'll participate Username:

I'll participate

Username: koffem

Rank: Member i think :D

Kent0526
Contributor
Contributor
WoM Member: 73606
WoM Coins: 299
Sign-ups are now closed.

We will be accepting no more participants.

teretere12
WoM Member
Members
WoM Member: 224406
WoM Coins: 0
SING UP

Username: kait
member

teretere12
WoM Member
Members
WoM Member: 224406
WoM Coins: 0
SING UP

Username: kait
member

Kent0526
Contributor
Contributor
WoM Member: 73606
WoM Coins: 299
And the contest has ended

The contest has ended, and I am awaiting the decisions of the other judges.

Minecraft Username: Artful
WoM Rank: Architect
Structure: 10
Interior: 7
Detail: 8
Design: 10
Notes: I like the modernness of it, compared with other cathedrals. However, the interior is very empty and simplistic, and the "stained glass" seems a little plain and uninteresting. Unique entry.
Minecraft Username: Dray2k
WoM Rank: Technician
Structure: 9
Interior: 5
Detail: 10
Design: 9
Notes: Interior is unfinished. The exterior, however, is AMAZING. The detail was extreme, and was hard to see in certain places, however. I like it, though.
Minecraft Username: Japetto9
WoM Rank: Designer
DISQUALIFIED - Missing a cathedral
AlphaCheeseGuy16
WoM Rank: Artist
DISQUALIFIED - Missing a cathedral
Minecraft Username: Swagalicos
WoM Rank: Technician
Structure: 7
Interior: 10
Detail: 8
Design: 10
Notes: Interior is amazing. The detail is lacking though, outside of the facade on the front. The roof is plain, and the sides are simplistic. Also, needs more spires, seeing as its a gothic period cathedral.
Minecraft Username: Danz360
WoM Rank: Designer
DISQUALIFIED - Where the cathedral?

Minecraft Username: JansenProjects

WoM Rank: Designer
DISQUALIFIED - Missing Cathedral
Minecraft Username: BizarreCake
WoM Rank: Surveyor
Structure: 5
Interior: 0
Detail: 8
Design: 9
Notes: Incomplete, theres only a facade. I like the toast shape, though.
Minecraft Username: greenitthe123
WoM Rank: Builder
DISQUALIFIED - Hah, giant block of sponge

Minecraft Username: My_name_is_Tuna
WoM Rank: designer
DISQUALIFIED - Missing Cathedral
Minecraft Username: MineCraftt
WoM Rank: Designer
DISQUALIFIED - Missing Cathedral
Minecraft Username: Eliethsor
WoM Rank: Artist
Structure: 10
Interior: 6
Detail: 9
Design: 10
Notes: Woah, this is amazing. Interior is empty, and theres a nasty checkered floor pattern in it. The sides are a little plain too. Otherwise, great job!
Minecraft Username: Comradeyeltsen

WoM Rank: Builder
Structure: 9
Interior: 6
Detail: 7
Design: 7
Notes: White and yellow. Some sand would've worked with this, too. I like it, though. Interior is somewhat empty, and theres a nice floor pattern, followed by grass. The detail is decent, nothing noteworthy, though.
Minecraft Username: Sinister_95
WoM Rank: Designer
DISQUALIFIED - Dammit, sin, you removed your awesome start.
Minecraft Username: Beardlessjoe
WoM Rank:  Builder
Structure: 2
Interior: 3
Detail: 1
Design: 3
Notes: Haha what is this. Huge lack of detail, its a giant box thats slightly curved at ends and top.
Minecraft Username: Gabriel365
WoM Rank: Surveyor
DISQUALIFIED - Lack of Cathedral
Minecraft Username: Dramaslims
WoM Rank: Designer
DISQUALIFIED - Missing a megastructure in the form of a cathedral. Come on, drama, make a dramatic cathedral.
Minecraft Username: Relik420
WoM Rank: Technician
DISQUALIFIED - You are a 024kiler, you should be able to kill me with shock at your cathedral.
Minecraft Username: TehDarkKnight
WoM Rank: Technician
DISQUALIFIED - You gave me prem, but you are missing a prem cathedral. I see little sections that appear to be planning, though
Minecraft Username: Joanan203
WoM Rank: Worker
DISQUALIFIED - Need I say anymore?
Minecraft Username: Sillyvader
WoM Rank: Surveyor
Structure: 1
Interior: 1
Detail: 1
Design: 1
Notes: Its a series of boxes with colored pyramid roofs. 
Minecraft Username: Joe3355

WoM Rank: Designer
DISQUALIFIED - All I see is an outline

Minecraft Username: koffem

WoM Rank: Member
Structure: 2
Interior: 1
Detail: 1
Design: 1
Its a box with curves for the windows and roofs with a bunch of crosses.
Minecraft Username: Psybeam524
Structure: 1
Interior: 3
Detail: 1
Design: 1
Notes: Its a giant box.

Kent0526
Contributor
Contributor
WoM Member: 73606
WoM Coins: 299
WINNERS

Edit: Sarari is gonna judge instead of procrastinate. Points will have to be recalculated.

ComradeYeltsen
WoM Member
Members
WoM Member: 130182
WoM Coins: 0
Well...

Wish I would have actually had time to finish mine lol

ryanknack
Member
Members
WoM Member: 173494
WoM Coins: 980
My results of judging

Minecraft Username: Artful
World of Minecraft Rank: Architect
Structure: 10
Interior 8.5
Detail: 9.5
Design: 10
Notes: Nice and modern, would like to see more in the inside because it seems sort of palin but I like it and kool glass.
Minecraft Username: Dray2k
Rank: Tech
Structure: 9.5
Interior: 4
Detail: 10
Design: 8
Notes: I love the exterior, but the interior is unfinished and could use more work. However nice cathedral.
Minecraft Username: Swagalicos
World of Minecraft Rank: Tech
Structure: 7.5
Interior: 10
Detail: 8.5
Design: 10
Notes: Astounding Interior, could use a bit more detail, sides are a little boring. But really, nice job!
MineCraft Username: BizarreCake
World of Minecraft Rank: Surveyor
Structure: 4
Interior: 0
Detail: 7.5
Design: 9
Notes: Looks like the interior was not even thought of, but nice design. (also looks like it wasn't done)
MineCraft Username: Eliethsor
World of Minecraft Rank: Artist
Structure: 10
Interior: 4.5
Detail: 10
Design: 9.5
Notes: Wicked cath! It looks like you really never focused on putting anything inside the interior, but the floor is pretty nice, love the scenery. Overall Nice job!
Username: Comradeyeltsen
Rank: Builder
Structure: 8
Interior: 4.5
Detail: 6
Design: 5.5
Notes: I noticed some random holes in the floor, detail is pretty much basic, some nice floor pattern, Good effort!
Username: Beardlessjoe
Rank: Builder
Structure: 1
Interior: 2
Detail: 1
Design: 2
Notes: I really didn’t really see any effort into detail. Honestly, It looks like a bulky box with a lot of open space. Nice attempt though.
Username: Sillyvader
Rank: Surveyor
Structure: 0
Interior: .5
Detail: 0
Design: 0
Notes: At first I didn’t even know what I was looking at, they looked all like boxes with a simple roof, and it just looks like you threw it together and called it a Cathedral, I am sorry but I would like to see better.
Username: koffem
Rank: Visitor
Structure: 2
Interior: .5
Detail: 1.5
Design: 1
Notes: looks like a weird box with windows without any detail and a roof and a leaf cross.
Username: Psybeam524
Rank: Designer
Structure: 1.5
Interior: 1
Detail: .5
Design: 2
Notes: Box with curves, looks like you just threw leaf around in the interior. Mediocre attempt of effort.

Artful
WoM Member
Members
WoM Member: 189505
WoM Coins: 103
eliethsors outside of it is 1

eliethsors outside of it is 1 tile on another tile.. and the sides of it is just 1 tile.. how does that = 10 detail?

ryanknack
Member
Members
WoM Member: 173494
WoM Coins: 980
jealousy?

jealousy?

Artful
WoM Member
Members
WoM Member: 189505
WoM Coins: 103
dont be a tard

dont be a tard

swagalicos
WoM Member
Members
WoM Member: 113462
WoM Coins: 31
be

be a tard....